Skip to main content
Blog post

Assessment lessons learned part 1: Notes from an educational developer

November 16, 2026
|
By Margo Echenberg, Educational Developer


Three people seated in a lounge area working on their devices. Two of the people are working on laptops and the third person is writing notes on paper.

Over the course of my two-decade long career as a literature professor, no part of my teaching changed as much as my assessment practices. Over the years, I presented students with different texts, but they consistently practiced reading, as well as learning to reflect, write, and discuss what they read. What did change were the ways in which I asked students to demonstrate what they knew or could do. I experimented with different assessment formats, from papers or essays to reading journals or responses, open-book exams, oral presentations, group work, creative multimedia projects and more. Provoking the change was some sense that I needed to adjust, either for reasons to do with me (e.g., my workload), my institution (e.g., increasing class size), or my students (e.g., every cohort read a little less). Whatever the case, my shifting assessment practices were all rather impromptu. I can’t say for certain that the changes were for the better. There were some that were more popular among students and others that I liked grading more. Unlike with my teaching, it’s fair to say that I never felt very satisfied that I was doing my best work when it came to the assessment process.

Since becoming an educational developer and working to support instructors around all moments of the assessment process (planning, designing/redesigning, grading and giving feedback), I can’t say I’ve been able to identify exactly what caused my assessment malaise. I have, nevertheless, learned to recognize aspects missing from how I carried out assessments that would likely have made for a better experience for both me and my students.  

In this blog post and the next (coming soon!), I outline some of the gaps I’ve identified, alongside ways of shifting my approach or practice and some pedagogical tips about why these matter.

Gap: Thinking that the assessments were appendages, separate from the teaching and learning happening in other parts of the course.

I thought of assessments as necessary but bothersome and I only gave them any thought after deciding on what and how I would teach. I certainly didn’t give much thought to any pedagogical reasoning for carrying out assessments.  

Shift: Conceiving of assessment as an integral part of the learning process. Then telling your students.

If assessments are a student’s opportunity to demonstrate what they’ve learned and/or can do, then it becomes essential to develop assessments that convey what the most important parts of the course are and where I need students to focus their efforts. Let’s say, for example, that two of my course’s learning outcomes involve developing critical, analytical skills as applied to a literary text and identifying and distinguishing different schools of literary theory. A group project in which students need to apply different critical lenses to the same text and then produce either an essay, a catalogue or a podcast would align with the course’s learning outcomes. Learn more and find recommendations on how to align assessments to learning outcomes.  

To clarify my expectations and to help my students focus on their learning, I’d make the alignment between the course learning outcomes and the project deliberate, detailing why I’d planned the assessment this way. 

Talking through my assessment design decisions is a way to improve students’ assessment literacy. Plus, being transparent around expectations and informing students how their grades are earned as well as allowing for some flexibility, are not only good assessment practices, they’re also inclusive pedagogical strategies that support all students’ learning and well-being while upholding academic rigor. Learn more in our Key concepts resource. 

Gap: Not intentionally planning when an assessment was formative or summative.

Shift: Making assessment decisions based on whether students need to be practicing what they’re learning or demonstrating skills, competence or proficiency. 

The aim is that your assessment tasks match and measure the most essential knowledge, skills, and values you intend for your students to develop in your course. But they don’t need to be practicing all of these things with every assessment task. You can give them practice opportunities over the term by asking them to do both formative and summative assessments. What’s the difference? 

Given its focus on practice, it can be helpful to think of formative assessment as assessment for learning. By giving students practice opportunities and encouraging them to monitor their learning based on feedback, this kind of assessment gives students more agency and can help them better achieve the learning outcomes. It can also help you track progress and identify gaps between your expectations and their learning. Formative assessment usually has low stakes, which means it has little or no point value in a student’s grade. Focusing on improving student learning early on and throughout the semester can also help ensure that students are adequately preparing for summative assessments.  

It can be helpful to think of summative assessment as assessment of learning. This type of assessment takes place at designated times in the semester (generally at the end of a unit or course) to measure or gauge learning and usually contributes with higher stakes to a student’s grade. In this type of assessment, students’ learning is measured against a predetermined standard.

If we use the example of the group project, the final essay, catalogue or podcast is the summative assessment, while some of the components of the project, such as a proposal or outline, are formative tasks that help students practice, prepare, and build on any feedback they’ve received. 

In the next post, I’ll review two more gaps I’ve identified: focusing more on the final product than on the process and failing to distinguish when students can develop parts individually in group work versus designing for collaboration.

Assessing students’ work may never become a part of your teaching practice that you love. It’s likely, though, that learning more about what makes for good assessments can shift your assessment design so that they’re more satisfactory for your students to complete and for you to mark.

Interested in ongoing conversations around assessment? Consider joining one of the CTL’s Faculty Interest Groups. Looking for pedagogical support around assessment? Reach out to the CTL: [email protected]

CTL resources linked in this post: